Why interviewers should score alone
Score before you confer, write evidence before the number, describe every point on the scale, and name what you actually mean instead of 'cultural fit'.
Score before you confer
The first opinion spoken in a debrief reshapes the room, and the most senior voice reshapes it most. Scores written in private are the only independent ones.
Evidence first, number second
Reversed, the number arrives as an impression and the evidence gets assembled to justify it. Panels arguing about evidence usually resolve; panels arguing about numbers rarely do.
Describe each point on the scale
'Rate communication 1 to 5' means five different things to five people. A line for what 1, 3 and 5 look like turns a scorecard from a mood ring into a measurement.
'Cultural fit' is where bias gets in
In practice it usually means 'reminds me of people who have done well here', which is how a team stays exactly as it is. Name the real thing instead and score it on evidence.
Read the full guide on iTalent Jobs